Sam’s Halloween 2026 candy haul
Pieces by item
Coffee Crisp is the most common wrapped bar by a wide margin.
Chocolate vs. everything else
The salty and chewy stuff barely registers.
The takeaways
Very Canadian bag. Coffee Crisp, Aero, Smarties, Wunderbar, Caramilk, Bear Paws and Maynards are mostly impossible to find at a US Target.
Mars barely showed up. Most neighbors clearly bought the same Nestlé variety box.
Trade value: Reese’s and Twix are the scarce assets, Coffee Crisp is the currency, and the lone Twirl is what you hand a younger sibling.